Top 7 Assisted Living Facilities in Brookhaven, NY

Made up of nine villages and 50 hamlets, Brookhaven is one of Long Island’s most populous towns, and according to AARP, more than 30% of the population is over the age of 50. Seniors who enjoy water sports and other coastal activities appreciate this island-spanning locale, which borders the Long Island Sound to the north and the Great South Bay to the south, providing access to beaches, boating and ferries that offer convenient transportation to mainland Connecticut. Brookhaven is part of the New York metropolitan area and just a short train ride away from Manhattan’s culture and attractions, including Broadway, Times Square, the Museum of Modern Art and the tree lighting at Rockefeller Center.

The town, which belongs to the AARP Network of Age-Friendly Communities, hosts over 25 complimentary senior citizen clubs, promoting socialization through structured activities, special events and outings. Brookhaven also offers Helping Hands, a residential repair program open to its 60-plus community, supplying free maintenance assistance for minor home improvements and repairs. The area is also close to some of the most advanced medical care in the world, including Manhattan’s Memorial Sloan-Kettering Cancer Center and the Hospital for Special Surgery. This guide covers Brookhaven’s top 7 assisted living programs for seniors considering a move to the area.

New Brookhaven Town House

Image of New Brookhaven Town House - exterior

111 Beaverdam Rd.
Brookhaven, NY 11719

(631) 286-2500

Offering a less restrictive option to nursing home care, this modern 182-bed assisted living community tailors its services to residents’ individual needs, allowing seniors to receive home health care directly at the facility. Located at the heart of Suffolk County, New Brookhaven Town House is just a short drive from the Bellport shopping outlets, the historic Gateway Playhouse and the region’s beautiful Atlantic Coast beaches. Seniors can choose a private studio apartment or companion suite, and the facility’s comfortable rooms come fully furnished.

Sunrise of Holbrook

Image of Sunrise of Holbrook - exterior

320 Patchogue Holbrook Rd.
Holbrook, NY 11741

(631) 983-6365

Located just minutes from the Great Patchogue Lake, Sunrise of Holbrook offers residents spectacular views of Long Island’s Pine Barrens while providing convenient access to Sunrise Highway and the Long Island Expressway. Individual and community spaces are designed for comfort and safety, and each resident is evaluated to create a personalized care plan. In 2017, this pet-friendly facility was awarded the AHCA/NCAL’s silver National Quality Award, which recognizes a commitment to outstanding senior care. We’re featuring Sunrise of Holbrook on our list of the top assisted living communities in Brookhaven because of its eight signature Live with Purpose programs, which deliver activities designed to foster health, creativity, spirituality and lifelong learning.

Village Walk at Patchogue

Image of Village Walk at Patchogue - exterior

131 E. Main St.
Patchogue, NY 11772

(631) 593-6140

Situated on Patchogue’s historic Main Street on the south shore of Long Island, this hospitality-based assisted living program encourages a balanced lifestyle with spaces designed for socializing and recreation. Village Walk at Patchogue has its own creative arts studio, a rooftop observation deck, waterfront access and multiple dining venues, including a bistro with an adjoining patio. Its central location provides easy access to shopping, dining and natural attractions, such as Fire Island National Seashore. Plentiful public transportation is available nearby, including buses, ferries and Patchogue’s Long Island Railroad station, which has regularly scheduled trains into Manhattan.

McPeak’s Assisted Living

Image of McPeak’s Assisted Living - exterior

286 N. Ocean Ave.
Patchogue, NY 11772

(631) 475-0445

Nestled in an established residential neighborhood just north of the bustling village of Patchogue, McPeak’s Assisted Living has convenient access to the Long Island Railroad, Long Island Expressway and several Great South Bay beaches, which are great for swimming. Seniors enjoy the homelike atmosphere of this converted mansion and can help shape their community by participating in resident council meetings. The facility offers a stimulating full-time recreational program that includes pet-assisted therapy, cultural activities and religious services for those who wish to worship. This family-owned and operated community makes our list of the area’s best assisted living facilities because of its ongoing gerontology training for staff members and its 50-plus years of experience caring for Suffolk County seniors.

The Bristal at Holtsville

Image of The Bristal at Holtsville - exterior

5535 Expressway Dr. N.
Holtsville, NY 11742

(631) 449-7430

Located midway between Montauk and Manhattan, The Bristal at Holtsville offers personalized assisted living services based on the evolving needs of each resident and designed to accommodate aging in place. The facility is known for its signature programs, including The Bristal Helping Hands, which fosters community integration by matching seniors with local service projects, and The Bristal Better U, which provides personal enrichment and lifelong learning opportunities in partnership with area universities. The community also offers an appetizing dining program to encourage good nutrition and to make food fun for residents through themed meals, chef-action stations and specialty cocktails at the on-site tavern. 

Hamlet at Medford

Image of Hamlet at Medford - exterior

1529 N. Ocean Ave.
Medford, NY 11763

(631) 289-0600

With decades of experience in residential senior services, The Hamlet at Medford (which now operates under the Braemar company name) upholds a high standard of senior care through its skilled professional team, on-site doctor’s offices and open communication between staff, residents and family members. This affordable facility has its own pub, beauty salon and a fully equipped gym. Residents who enjoy outdoor time have access to a multitude of walking paths as well as the community’s shuffleboard court and putting green. The Hamlet at Medford regularly shuttles residents to local restaurants, shopping centers and places of worship, promoting an active lifestyle and interaction with the outside community. The facility is easily accessible via the Long Island Expressway or from mainland Connecticut via the Port Jefferson ferry.

Pleasant Gardens Home for Adults

Image of Pleasant Gardens Home for Adults - exterior

396 Middle Rd.
Bayport, NY 11705

(800) 385-2527

With its desirable location on Long Island’s scenic South Shore, it’s no surprise that the Pleasant Gardens Home for Adults was once a summer getaway destination. This intimate 26-resident facility, which is now run by Mercy Haven, dates back to 1787 and currently offers a community for adults who require assistance to live independently. The facility’s Growing Together Community Garden project brings together residents and area citizens to grow fresh food, foster a sense of community and feed the spirit of everyone involved. Pleasant Gardens makes our list of Brookhaven’s best assisted living providers because of its historic charm and pleasing location. The facility is just a short drive from Loughlin Vineyard, the Bayport Aerodrome and the calm beaches of the Great South Bay.

Is Brookhaven the right choice for you?

Known for its blend of Mid-Atlantic seashore charm and suburban convenience, this senior-friendly town delivers the best of both worlds. From quaint port villages to big-city entertainment, residents of Brookhaven have it all at their fingertips. Seniors who appreciate fresh seafood, open-water swimming and a casual coastal lifestyle may find the Town of Brookhaven the perfect place to call home. 

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *